Catching Up: Zurich, Grenke
The Korchnoi memorial event in Zurich finished a few days ago, and Hikaru Nakamura won this combined rapid & rapid event. (The first stage was a slow rapid: 45' + 30", and the second was 10' + 5" - a rapid rapid.) The slower portion finished with Hikaru Nakamura and Ian Nepomniachtchi tied in first with 10/14 (5/7 in normal scoring, but as the slower games counted for twice as much as the blitz, the scoring was doubled), a point ahead of Viswanathan Anand and two points ahead of Vladimir Kramnik and Peter Svidler.
At the shorter time control Nakamura again went 5/7, winning the second portion of the event outright and thereby taking overall first as well. It came down to the wire though, as Nepomniachtchi had White against Grigoriy Oparin. Oparin is young, strong, and talented, but for now he was badly outrated by everyone except for local player Yannick Pelletier. He and Pelletier were the tailenders, so things looked good for Nepo. Had he won he'd have tied for first, and presumably would have had a playoff against Nakamura. Instead, Oparin won, giving Nakamura his third consecutive victory in Zurich.
Final Combined Standings:
- 1. Nakamura 15/21
- 2. Nepomniachtchi 14
- 3. Anand 13.5
- 4. Svidler 12
- 5. Kramnik 11
- 6. Gelfand 9
- 7. Oparin 5.5
- 8. Pelletier 4
Grenke: This tournament got off to a bang when Hou Yifan won her first two games, over Fabiano Caruana and Georg Meier, to take a full point lead over a field that also included Magnus Carlsen, Maxime Vachier-Lagrave, and Levon Aronian as well. Incredibly, she was close to winning in round three against Carlsen as well, but psyched herself out and let him escape his bad position rather easily with a draw.
Her punishment was deserved and came in the very next round. Vachier-Lagrave had a much smaller advantage against her than she had against Carlsen, but he kept prodding and testing until she finally cracked. It took 68 moves, but he got the full point, pushing her out of first. The next day she gave up a draw to one of the two players in the event who are lower-rated than she is, so she has fallen out of contention for tournament victory.
And yet...she is still tied for second, with Carlsen and Caruana, with 3/5, a point behind Levon Aronian. Aronian drew with Meier and Carlsen in the first two rounds, and then went on a tear, winning three in a row. He has defeated MVL, Mathias Bluebaum, and Arkadij Naiditsch. In the next round he plays Hou Yifan, with White. Will he make it four in a row, or will she bounce back and turn this into the tournament of her life?
Carlsen also has an interesting pairing, with Black against Naiditsch. Carlsen is a favorite, of course, but in the last few years Naiditsch has given him trouble. Naiditsch upset the world champion in the 2014 Olympiad, with Black, and took a couple of games off of him in the same tournament two years ago. As for Caruana, he'll have Black in the next round against Bluebaum.
Reader Comments (2)
"Had he (Nepomniachtchi) won he'd have tied for first, and presumably would have had a playoff against Nakamura."
Indeed, live commentators apparently mentioned a possible playoff (I didn't watch live, my secondary source is Sam Copeland writing for chess.com). But the final report on the tournament site states that Nakamura would have had superior Sonneborn-Berger (basically because he won his first game against Nepo) - not talking about a playoff, thus it seems that Nakamura would have been declared winner of the event.
Zurich history comes to (my) mind: Nakamura shared first place with Anand in 2015 and 2016. In 2015, Anand had superior Sonneborn-Berger and there was a controversial playoff. Controversial because it apparently wasn't foreseen by tournament regulations, but rules were spontaneously changed during the final day. Anand protested before and, some say, also during the Armaggedon game - which wasn't quite as drastic as Hou Yifan - Ganguly (1.g4 etc.) but somewhat close. In 2016, Nakamura had superior Sonneborn-Berger (decided by a last-round game between tailenders Giri and Shirov) and there was no playoff.
"Zurich rules" can thus be interpreted as: If Sonneborn-Berger favors Nakamura - no change of regulations, no playoff. If Sonneborn-Berger doesn't favor Nakamura - ad hoc playoff.
"Her punishment was deserved and came in the very next round. Vachier-Lagrave had a much smaller advantage against her than she had against Carlsen, but he kept prodding and testing until she finally cracked. It took 68 moves, but he got the full point, pushing her out of first. The next day she gave up a draw to one of the two players in the event who are lower-rated than she is, so she has fallen out of contention for tournament victory."
Spot on comments for failing to press Carlsen when she had the better position and what seems like inferior opening preparation against Bluebaum.
Looks like the next female chess player in the top ten is not among the current crop of twenty somethings. Are there any female IM/GMs in their teens that look to have the potential to become a world championship challenger?